The fourth adoption pattern shows an emerging trend, where the drive toward modernization comes from the right side of the quadrant. For example, operations may want to improve or modernize practices. The technology and approaches are good enough for the moment.

continuous delivery maturity model

Recommendation for ResearchersThe contributions of this study for academics is the confirmation of the maturity model developed by Patel and Ramachandran . This study also shows the association between the individual activities within the maturity levels as well as the maturity levels and the perceived project success, addressing a gap in literature relating these concepts. At this level test automation is used from end-to-end across the pipeline. Dev and QA teams cooperate to ensure a good level of test coverage is automated. Success with DevOps requires a mature approach to continuous automated testing.

Please use, generate link and share the link here. Faster than following manual instructions due to automated scripting. The Operations team pushes the package into a test environment, the package is tested by the Testing team. Identifying areas where there is scope for improvement becomes easier.

Continuous Delivery just means that you are able to do frequent deployments but may choose not to do it, usually due to businesses preferring a slower rate of deployment. In order to do Continuous Deployment you must be doing Continuous Delivery. At this level there is little evidence of test automation skills, test automation processes are not apparent and test automation technology has major gaps. Continuous Integration is a software development practice that aims for a frequent integration of individual pieces of work. Commonly each person integrates at least once per day giving place to several integrations during the day. Each integration should be verified by an automated Build Verification Test .

Different Stages Of Maturity

This also is a quick way to determine areas to address to improve the level of maturity. To use maturity models or not is an eternal question that Agile and DevOps coaches struggle with. We all know that maturity models have some weaknesses, they can easily be gamed if they are used to incentivise and/or punish people, they are very prone to the Dunning-Kruger effect and often they are vague. Using a continuous deliverymaturity model can facilitate discussions on what you want to achieve with CI/CD and will help you map out a step-by-step approach to implementing the various elements.

At one of my recent clients we performed many maturity assessments across a wide variety of teams, technologies and applications. Of course such large scope means that we did not spend a lot of time with each team to assess the maturity and not surprisingly the result was that we got very different levels of response. It’s important to make sure database changes be taken into consideration when releasing to production. Otherwise, your release team will be working late at night trying to finish up a release with manual steps that are error-prone and nearly impossible to rollback. As you continue to build out the pipeline, your team will need to collaborate more closely with other functions and start taking more responsibility for delivering your software. To do that, they need visibility of how the software performs in production and for the rest of the organization to be bought into the approach.

continuous delivery maturity model

There is a focus on end-to-end performance trends rather than spot results. Automation is applied to test environment orchestration and analytics. The second pattern is similar to the first, but here the movement toward DevOps modernization begins within the development team embracing agile practices through the adoption of CI. This is a common starting point because development teams are continuous delivery maturity model able to adopt CI processes and tools independent of other stakeholders. The DevOps maturity for application is defined by how secure the code development process is, right from development to production stage. Delivering on this aspect of maturity requires extensive builds, tests, security scans, code coverage, and constant monitoring of the automated elements in the deployment pipeline.


Building up your pipeline incrementally, with achievable goals along the way, makes the process more manageable and provides opportunities to take stock and learn from what you have done so far. As CI speeds up the coding and building steps, teams seek to increase flow by adopting agile definition and planning practices. These organizations then follow the path of adoption pattern 1.

During pipeline execution large amounts of data can be produced. If this information is not dealt with efficiently it can become a waste product, detracting from the value of the delivery process. You must be adopting robust processes to measure key metrics – PuppetLab’s report focuses on improvement in 4 key metrics – Change Frequency, Change Lead Time, Change Failure Rate and MTTR. We suggest Availability, Performance and MTBF should be in there too. The DevOps Quadrant Maturity Model includes four quadrants that position development practices along the two axes of DevOps adoption . Continuous Integration is about how developers integrate code using a shared repository multiple times a day with the help of automation.

continuous delivery maturity model

This will allow the testing each modification made in order to guarantee a good QA. Even the daily or weekly release of code will produce a report that will be sent every early morning. To accomplish this you can install the Selenium app in Clarive. In this blog post, we will be exposing maturity level checklists for different DevOps areas so you have an idea where you at in terms of Continuous Delivery.

Acceptance Criteria For Release Management Maturity Model

Previously, he served as an Editor for PC World Philippines and Questex Asia, as well as a Designer for Tropa Entertainment. The final stage of maturity involves full automation and advanced routing. The expert stage also introduces the concept of GitOps, which according to Curtis, means that everything is in a declarative state in versioned artifacts, so the environment itself describes how it should run. 100% of Integration tests are automated, automated regression tests are integrated together with the code changes. Schedule a demo with one of our specialists and start improving your devops practices. Testing automatization can be in code, systems, service etc.

  • The smaller the window in which change can happen in the old version while you are trying to release the new the better.
  • Applying these four patterns to the maturity model provides a foundation for discussing a company’s DevOps journey.
  • Working quickly, deploying frequently and developing on the fly means that teams learn faster from mistakes and are able to remain ahead of competitors, as well as responding intuitively to the needs of their audience.
  • Embracing DevOps as a continuous journey and not a destination is crucial to attaining DevOps maturity.
  • The DevOps journey is now at a stage where most companies have implemented it at some level and in some form in their software development and IT processes.

These automated tests can detect errors just in time so they can be fixed before they create more problems in the future. This helps to reduce a lot of integration issues since this practice allows to develop faster and in a more efficient way. The primary focus of step four is to ensure that the working practice, training and operating procedures remain consistent. Standardization allows for continuous improvement and each of the first 3S’s should be regulated.

What Computer Games Can Teach Us About Maturity Models

Data is not only easily accessible and easily shared among participants, but new business opportunities can be rapidly achieved in a cost effective way, as they are no longer blocked by technology impediments. Consider the journey between data provider, data enricher, data consumer, and end-user. Level 3 applications may provide transparency across one hop of that journey, but not multiple hops. Level 4 — Competitive — Using modern technology and practices exclusively but still constrained by a limited set of technologies and practices. Level 4 companies have optimized their technology usage within their organization and are exploring whether further optimization outside their organization or across clouds may be possible. Level 3 — Adequate — Applying modern technology and practices in many areas but still not reaping the full benefits.

An organization’s ability to mature its DevOps processes is governed by the robustness of its foundations – determined by application architecture. It is one of the determining factors in whether an organization will be able to leverage DevOps for rapid-release cadence. If your system is not designed to support quick, frequent, and easy testing, you will end up with bottlenecks no matter what.

I explained why continuous test automation is important to improve both agility and quality at the same time, as expected with DevOps transformations. Five levels of continuous test automation maturity were described. It was explained how to use the continuous test automation maturity model to assess the maturity of an organization and to identify improvements that will improve maturity. For more information readers are encouraged to review the material in my book “Engineering DevOps” and on my website

Information Security Management

Once you have established the foundations, you can look towards automating the first stages of your pipeline by extending your automated tests and collaborating with operations teams on the creation of pre-production environments. Leanmanufacturing has been using the 5S pratice as a common method for lean implementation for years. Nearly 70% of of lean manufacturing companies use this approach 7, but the use of 5S as an adoption method for lean in software development would appear less common, as it has not be commonly applied to development practices. The adoption of Kaizen events to implement 5s within the Continuous Delivery pipeline can provide significant support to maturing the model, by providing a continuous improvement process within a well-defined and standardized structure.

These measures should enable you to set sensible incremental targets for improvement. Over time you can ratchet up your expectations and so continue to move the organisation on. Continuous Deployment is about releasing software to production automatically without human intervention. Continuous Delivery is about automatically releasing software to the test or production environment. While automation plays a key role in the effectiveness of DevOps processes, it can yield results only when based on well-defined workflows.

Knowledge Management

It is easy to replace technology for the benefit of something better . Adopt the habit of auditing regularly and reward the best teams. Education – 5s methodology, concepts and practices need to be communicated. Visually distinguish or categorize key pipeline components.

Quick Check Your Continuous Delivery Maturity

This article includes a list of related items that share the same name . Updated on 12 August 2014 to add text on benefits and deploying to a subset of users. Large «enterprise» suites claiming they can solve all your problems. Chooses technology stack based on what is best for each purpose. Feature toggling to switch on/off functionality in production.

Technology that makes it simple to roll back and forth between database versions. In depth knowledge about each technology; why it is used and how it works. Almost all testing is automated, also for non-functional requirements.

A Maturity Model For Continuous Delivery

Level 5 organizations are building new businesses that leverage new partnerships and influential ecosystems, supported by modern technology, that weren’t previously fathomable. Application Platform — The services to consume, produce, and act on Application Data, and the interfaces and integrations needed to develop new features quickly. Think of this as the clouds adopted, the cloud-native services supported, the interaction patterns possible, and integrations available, which together use the data fuel to do something productive. At higher maturity levels, less code and fewer third-party services are required to enable the desired outcome as more functionality moves on-platform. In this article, I presented a blueprint for mature continuous test automation.

Level 3 companies are well on their way to realizing their initial cloud strategy, likely drafted a number of years ago, but have not refined their initial strategy to account for the changes in the competitive landscape around them. Think of this as the ability to easily create an ecosystem and the ability to support that ecosystem’s heterogeneous needs. There is no option to jump over some levels, for example from first to fifth, just excluding levels between, each level should follow the previous one from left to right. There can be different maturity levels regarding each model area and organization can choose different desired levels in each area, too. Each of the model cells includes goals, relevant to the corresponding maturity level and area, which describes points which should be realized to comply with relevant maturity level in specific area. On the flip side, getting results of continuous testing right means accelerating the time-to-market, improving code quality, developing a mechanism for continuous feedback, and eliminating the gap between development, testing, and operations.

Continuous Deployment is an advancement and it reduces manual work of the Operations and Testing team to deploy the software to production as it is automatically deployed to production after Automated Acceptance Testing. The DevOps Maturity Model can help you enhance the efficiency of the entire workflow, decrease the time-to-market while improving release cycles, augmenting product quality and test accuracy. With clear insights on where you stand in your DevOps journey, you are better equipped to evolve into a highly matured environment on an organizational level in a shorter time span. DevOps has transformed the way the IT industry operates by redefining the paradigms of workflow and method chain. As DevOps enters its second decade, the scope and focus of its application are expanding well beyond product delivery. One of the major impediments in any organization’s DevOps transition is the outlook of using it as a goal or a destination.

All changes (code, configuration, environments, etc.) triggers the feedback mechanisms. Feedback on database performance and deployment for each release. Data generated in the pipeline is likely to include instrumentation, metrics and logging information, as well as build artifacts and report data. Once the waste has been removed and only what is required has been kept and ordered, the next phase inspects the delivery pipeline to ensure that it’s operation is as clean as possible.

Once achieved, DevOps engineers have more time to focus on creating new features. The maturity model concept has been applied to city planning practices, such as planning to encourage participation in cycling. The key test is that a business sponsor could request that the current development version of the software can be deployed into production at a moment’s notice — and nobody would bat an eyelid, let alone panic.